Incogni vs DeleteMe vs Aura (2026): We Tested All Three — Here's What Matters

Joel DeJong
Tested & Reviewed
View full bio
Dolores Maxinne Bernal
Writer
View full bio
Brandon King
Founder & Editor-in-Chief
View full bio

Incogni vs DeleteMe vs Aura: Quick Verdict

We tested all three with real identities and real removal requests. Here is the short version:

  • DeleteMe is the best data broker removal service — 976 sites, human-verified removals, dedicated privacy advisor, quarterly reports. $10.75/month.
  • Incogni is the fastest and cheapest — 420+ sites, fully automated, Deloitte-audited. $7.99/month.
  • Aura is the best choice if you need more than removal — credit monitoring, dark web scanning, $1M insurance, 24/7 fraud resolution, plus 425+ site removal. $12/month.

DeleteMe and Incogni remove your data from broker sites. Aura does that and protects you from what happens after — credit fraud, dark web leaks, account takeovers. Which you need depends on whether your concern stops at “get my name off Spokeo” or extends to “alert me if someone opens a credit card in my name.”

How We Tested Incogni, DeleteMe, and Aura

We did not just sign up, screenshot the dashboard, and repeat back the marketing materials. Our team tested these services with real identities, real data, and real removal requests — then measured what actually happened.

We tracked how many exposures each service found, how many removal requests were submitted, how many got completed, and how fast they followed up. We also tested customer service — phone pickup times, email response speed, whether support tried to upsell us on the call.

Here is what the numbers looked like:

  • DeleteMe reviewed 3,610 listings and removed from 57 in the first quarterly report. In a fresh-account test, a new tester saw 22 removal requests submitted with 12 actively pending — real workflow stages, not instant “complete” marks
  • Incogni sent 123 removal requests and completed 60 in roughly one week — fast, automatic, no manual effort required
  • Aura triggered 14 dark web alerts on first sign-up, including three credential exposures that other services we were testing missed entirely. A test credit application triggered a notification in under five minutes

We also spot-checked whether removals actually stuck. When DeleteMe’s report said a listing was gone, we went to the broker site and verified — the information was actually removed. That verification matters more than the number on the dashboard.

Incogni vs DeleteMe vs Aura — Which Should You Get?
FeatureDeleteMeIncogniAura
Best ForMost thorough removalFastest, cheapest removalFull identity protection
Data Broker Removal
Broker sites✅ 976420+425+ (growing)
Removal method✅ Human-verifiedAutomated (Deloitte-audited)Automated
Human privacy advisor✅ Every account❌❌
Custom removal requests✅❌❌
Quarterly reports✅ Detailed PDF❌ Monthly dashboard❌ Dashboard only
Identity Theft Protection
Dark web monitoring❌❌✅ (14 alerts on first scan)
Credit monitoring❌❌✅ Real-time, 3 bureaus
Financial account monitoring❌❌✅ Banks, cards, investments
Identity theft insurance❌❌✅ Up to $1M/adult
24/7 fraud support❌❌✅ US-based, real people
VPN + antivirus❌❌✅
Pricing & Availability
Starting price~$10.75/mo$7.99/mo~$12/mo
Monthly billing❌ Annual only✅✅
International coverageUS, UK, EU, CA, AU✅ US, UK, EU, CAUS
Save 20% on DeleteMe 60% OFF INCOGNI
Code SECURITYHERO
Get Aura Protection

Where Each Service Wins

DeleteMe Wins on the Human Element

DeleteMe advertises 976 data broker sites covered — likely the biggest number you will find in this space. But that number comes with a nuance worth understanding: not all 976 sites are fully automatic. A portion of that coverage comes from custom removals, where DeleteMe’s team handles the request but you may need to flag specific listings through their dashboard.

That is actually the trade-off that makes DeleteMe work. It is more report-driven and hands-on, which gives you more visibility into what information was found, what was removed, and where you may need to take additional action. Real people — DeleteMe calls them privacy advisors — look through your exposed data to determine which listings are actual threats, then submit removal requests manually and verify each one actually stuck.

When we spot-checked our results, the information DeleteMe said was gone was actually gone. At $10.75/month, you are paying for human eyes on your data — and in our testing, that showed through in the final result.

Save 20% on DeleteMe →

Incogni Wins on Speed and Price

Incogni is the exact opposite of DeleteMe’s approach. It is built around pure automation — you enter your information and Incogni starts submitting removal requests to all 420+ sites in its network without you lifting a finger. The removal processes have been independently audited by Deloitte.

The appeal is speed and simplicity. You do not need to spend time reviewing which sites found your information or deciding which listings to prioritize. Incogni handles everything automatically and updates its dashboard monthly with filters for threat level, request status, and database type.

The trade-off is precision and visibility. Incogni is easier to use, but it gives you less control over the process. You do not get the quarterly PDF reports DeleteMe provides, you do not get a human advisor reviewing your case, and you cannot flag custom sites for removal.

At $7.99/month, Incogni is the cheapest dedicated data broker removal service in this comparison. It also works internationally (US, UK, EU, Canada) and offers monthly billing — no annual commitment required. If you already have identity theft protection elsewhere and just need a fast, affordable removal add-on, Incogni is the strongest pick.

60% OFF Incogni → Code SECURITYHERO

Aura Wins on Everything After Removal

Here is where the conversation shifts — because Aura is not trying to be the best data broker removal service. It is trying to solve a different problem entirely.

You can remove your phone number from Spokeo and your address from Whitepages. DeleteMe, Incogni, or Aura can all do that. But what about all the information that has already been copied off these sites? What if your email credentials or Social Security number got leaked on the dark web from a data breach? Removing a people-search listing does not undo that.

When we first signed up for Aura, we received 14 dark web alerts — including three credential exposures for active sign-in accounts that other services we were testing missed entirely. A test credit card application triggered an Aura notification in under five minutes. We called support at midnight on a Friday and got a real person in under a minute — no script, no upsell. They followed up a week later to make sure everything was sorted.

What Aura includes that neither DeleteMe nor Incogni offers:

  • Data broker removal from 425+ sites (growing — up from ~35 just 18 months ago)
  • Three-bureau credit monitoring on every plan — not just premium tiers
  • Dark web monitoring that caught credentials other services missed
  • Financial account monitoring — bank accounts, credit cards, investment accounts
  • $1 million identity theft insurance per adult
  • 24/7 US-based fraud resolution with real people
  • VPN, antivirus, password manager, and parental controls

At $12/month on the annual plan, you are getting data broker removal plus everything needed to detect, stop, and recover from identity theft — before, during, and after an incident. Aura is not a data broker removal service with extras tacked on. It is an identity theft protection suite that happens to include removal.

Get Aura — Save up to 68% →

Is Data Broker Removal Enough to Protect You?

This is the question that separates these three services into two categories.

DeleteMe and Incogni are data broker removal services. They scan for your personal information on people-search sites, submit opt-out requests, and monitor for reappearance. That is the full scope of what they do — and they do it well.

Aura is an identity theft protection platform that includes removal as one layer. It covers the data broker problem and the threats that come after: credit fraud, dark web exposure, account takeovers, financial monitoring, and recovery.

The FTC’s numbers make the case: $15.9 billion in reported fraud losses in 2025. Data broker removal addresses the visibility problem — your name, address, and phone number appearing on searchable sites. Identity theft protection addresses what happens when someone uses your exposed data to open accounts, drain a bank, or file taxes in your name. Those are different threats requiring different tools.

If your only concern is getting your information off people-search sites, DeleteMe or Incogni is sufficient. If you are worried about what happens next — and the $15.9 billion in annual fraud losses says you probably should be — you need the protection layer too.

Pricing: DeleteMe vs Incogni vs Aura

PlanDeleteMeIncogniAura
MonthlyNot availableAvailableAvailable
Annual (1 person)$10.75/mo ($129/yr)$7.99/mo~$12/mo
Annual (2 people)$16.50/mo ($198/yr)Family plan available~$15/mo
2-Year (1 person)~$8.25/mo ($198/2yr)Not availableNot available

Cheapest removal: Incogni at $7.99/month — fast, automated, no commitment required.

Most coverage per dollar: DeleteMe’s 2-year plan at ~$8.25/month — 976 sites with human-verified removals.

Most value overall: Aura at ~$12/month — removal plus credit monitoring, dark web scanning, financial monitoring, $1M insurance, VPN, antivirus, and fraud support in one subscription.

Who Should Choose Which Service?

Choose DeleteMe if:

  • You want the most thorough data broker removal with human verification
  • Quarterly reports and documented removals matter to you
  • Custom removal requests are important for your situation
  • You already have identity theft protection through another service
  • You are comfortable with an annual commitment at $10.75/month

Choose Incogni if:

  • You want the fastest, most hands-off removal experience
  • Budget matters — $7.99/month is the cheapest dedicated option
  • You want monthly billing without a long-term commitment
  • You live outside the US (UK, EU, Canada)
  • You already have identity theft protection elsewhere and need a removal add-on

Choose Aura if:

  • You do not already have identity theft protection
  • You want removal and protection under one subscription
  • Credit monitoring across all three bureaus matters
  • Dark web monitoring is important — Aura caught exposures others missed
  • You want $1M insurance and 24/7 fraud support as a safety net
  • You prefer one service over managing DeleteMe + a separate identity protection plan

Incogni vs DeleteMe vs Aura FAQ

Which is better — Incogni, DeleteMe, or Aura?

DeleteMe is the best data broker removal service — 976 sites with human-verified removals and quarterly reports you can actually read. Incogni is the most hands-off and cheapest at $7.99/month. Aura is the best choice if you want protection beyond removal — credit monitoring, dark web scanning, $1M insurance, and 24/7 fraud resolution. The real question is whether you need removal only or removal plus identity theft protection.

How many data broker sites does each service cover?

DeleteMe covers 976 sites — the widest in the industry, though a portion requires custom removal requests rather than fully automatic processing. Incogni covers 420+ sites with fully automated removal. Aura covers 425+ and growing. The average person has 40–60 genuinely dangerous listings regardless of which service they use.

Does Incogni or DeleteMe include credit monitoring?

No. Neither Incogni nor DeleteMe monitors your credit — both focus exclusively on data broker removal. Aura includes real-time three-bureau credit monitoring (Equifax, TransUnion, Experian) on every plan, not just premium tiers.

Is data broker removal enough to protect against identity theft?

No. Data broker removal cleans up what is currently searchable about you online, but it cannot undo the copying, sharing, and selling your information has already gone through. The FTC reported $15.9 billion in fraud losses in 2025 — up 430% since 2020. If your SSN or credentials are already on the dark web from a breach, no removal service can retrieve them. That is why Aura exists — it covers the threats that come after removal.

Can I use DeleteMe and Aura together?

Yes, and it is one of the strongest combinations available. DeleteMe handles maximum broker coverage (976 sites with human-verified removals) while Aura handles identity protection — credit monitoring, dark web scanning, fraud resolution, and $1M insurance. The combined cost is roughly $23/month.

Is Incogni worth it on a budget?

Yes. At $7.99/month, Incogni is the cheapest dedicated data broker removal service. It covers 420+ sites with Deloitte-audited processes, works internationally (US, UK, EU, Canada), and requires zero manual effort. If you already have identity theft protection elsewhere, Incogni is a strong add-on.

Do any of these services monitor the dark web?

Only Aura. On first sign-up, our tester received 14 dark web alerts — including three credential exposures that other services missed entirely. Neither DeleteMe nor Incogni scans the dark web. Both focus exclusively on publicly visible data broker sites.

What is the real difference between DeleteMe, Incogni, and Aura?

DeleteMe and Incogni are data broker removal services — they find your information on people-search sites and submit opt-out requests. Aura is an identity theft protection platform that includes data broker removal as one layer. The difference matters because removing your listing from Spokeo does not protect you if your SSN was leaked in a data breach. Aura covers both scenarios. DeleteMe and Incogni cover only the first.

Incogni vs DeleteMe vs Aura: Our Final Verdict

The question is not which service removes the most broker sites. The question is what you actually need protection from.

  • Need removal only → DeleteMe. 976 sites, human-verified removals, dedicated privacy advisor, detailed quarterly reports. The specialist pick for people who already have identity theft protection elsewhere. $10.75/month.
  • Need removal on a budget → Incogni. 420+ sites, fully automated, Deloitte-audited, international coverage, monthly billing. The cheapest option that still delivers real results. $7.99/month.
  • Need removal + identity protection → Aura. Data broker removal from 425+ sites plus three-bureau credit monitoring, dark web scanning that caught exposures others missed, financial account monitoring, $1M insurance, 24/7 fraud support, VPN, and antivirus. One subscription instead of stacking multiple services. $12/month.

If you are not sure: ask yourself whether your concern stops at “I want my name off Spokeo” or extends to “I want to know if someone opens a credit card in my name.” The first is a removal problem. The second is an identity theft problem. Choose accordingly.

Related: Incogni vs DeleteMe | Aura vs DeleteMe | Best Data Broker Removal Services | DeleteMe vs Optery vs Aura

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up through them, at no extra cost to you. This never influences our editorial ratings or recommendations. Learn more.